Category: Agreements

When you are making plans for a shared future, it can feel uncomfortable to talk about worst-case scenarios. Having those conversations early, particularly when the relationship is happy and healthy, can give you clarity, reduce conflict later, and help you make thoughtful decisions about money, property, and expectations.

At BKW Family Law LLC, we work with individuals and families throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey who want practical guidance through sensitive family law decisions. In many situations, the right agreement can help you protect your interests while also creating a clearer path forward.

If you are thinking about a prenuptial, postnuptial, or cohabitation agreement, it can help to start with an overview of how these arrangements work and when they may make sense. Our family lawyers regularly help clients review their options and reach agreements before a problem becomes more stressful or more expensive. Several types of agreements may be available in family law matters, depending on the timing and circumstances.

Prenuptial Agreements Before Marriage

A prenuptial agreement is a contract signed before marriage. It can address how certain assets or debts will be treated if the marriage ends or if one spouse dies. It can also include or exclude specific assets and liabilities from consideration in a divorce. For some couples, that may include protecting a business, family wealth, real estate, retirement savings, or property acquired before the wedding.

These agreements are not only for high-net-worth households. They can also be useful when one person is entering the marriage with more debt, when either party wants to preserve separate property, or when the couple simply wants to avoid confusion later. Pre-nuptial agreements are also very helpful when the parties have children from prior relationships and are seeking to protect certain assets for those children.  A lawyer can help you think through what should be covered and whether the terms are realistic and enforceable.

Just as important, a prenuptial agreement should be discussed well before the wedding. Rushed conversations can create avoidable tension. When you have time to talk things through, ask questions, and review the document carefully, you are more likely to end up with an agreement that reflects your goals and feels fair to both people.

Postnuptial Agreements 

A postnuptial agreement is similar, but it is signed after a couple is already married. These agreements can be entered into whether the parties are separating and contemplating divorce or not.  Some people consider this option after a major financial change, such as starting a business, receiving an inheritance, or taking on new debt. Others use it when they want to clarify expectations during a difficult period in the marriage. Postnuptial agreements can also be entered when the parties are separated and are looking to resolve the economic issues related to separation and divorce.

Postnuptial agreements can be helpful, but they should be handled with care. Because the parties are already married, the circumstances around the agreement often matter a great deal. An attorney should make sure the document is clear, voluntary, and based on full financial information. That helps reduce the chance of a future dispute over the validity or enforceability of the agreement.

For couples who want more predictability without escalating conflict, a postnuptial agreement can sometimes be part of a broader plan to stabilize the relationship and define responsibilities more clearly.

Cohabitation Agreements for Unmarried Couples

Couples do not need to be married to benefit from a written agreement. A cohabitation agreement can help unmarried partners define how they will handle shared expenses, property ownership, and financial responsibilities while living together. It can also address what happens if the relationship ends.

This can be especially important when one person contributes more to a home purchase, when both partners invest in a shared property, or when they want to avoid misunderstandings about joint accounts or household bills. Without a written agreement, those issues can quickly become emotional and legally complicated.

Our attorneys often remind clients that a cohabitation agreement is not about distrust; it is about setting expectations while communication is still productive. A law firm that understands both the emotional and legal side of family matters can help you create an agreement that fits your actual situation instead of relying on assumptions.

How Mediation and ADR Can Support Agreement Planning

Not every agreement needs to grow out of conflict. In many cases, couples can reach thoughtful decisions through mediation or other forms of alternative dispute resolution (ADR). ADR refers to methods of resolving legal issues outside of a courtroom, which may allow for more privacy, more flexibility, and a less adversarial process.

This approach can be particularly helpful when both people want to be heard and are trying to preserve a working relationship. That may be true for engaged couples discussing a prenup, spouses revisiting financial expectations, or unmarried partners who want a clear framework for living together.

We often help clients explore whether negotiation, mediation, or another out-of-court process makes sense before turning to litigation. For many individuals and families, that approach feels more consistent with the respectful, solutions-focused outcome they want.

What to Consider Before You Sign

No matter which type of agreement you are considering, the details matter. The document should be tailored to your circumstances, written clearly, and based on complete financial disclosure. It should also be reviewed carefully so you understand what rights or obligations it creates.

This is one reason many couples benefit from having separate legal counsel. A lawyer can explain terms that may sound technical at first and also make sure the agreement meets the requirements that the courts of Pennsylvania and New Jersey have established for valid agreements.

Agreements are rarely one-size-fits-all. What works for one couple may not work for another, especially when the relationship, finances, or long-term goals are different. The best agreements are practical, balanced, and built around the people who will actually live under them.

Guidance for Clients in Pennsylvania and New Jersey

If you are considering an agreement as part of a marriage, separation, or long-term partnership, it is worth getting advice early. The right planning can reduce uncertainty and help you move forward with more confidence. It can also help you avoid mistakes that may be difficult to fix later.

Whether you are in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, or another community we serve, our lawyers understand that these conversations are personal. We aim to offer guidance that is experienced, steady, and approachable, so you feel informed rather than overwhelmed.

If you would like to talk through your options, contact our family law team to schedule a confidential consultation.

Full House? Why Wait? Mediate!

Is your house feeling a little too FULL lately? Mary-Kate Olsen, former child star of the television sitcom “Full House” thought so recently when she asked a Manhattan, New York court to grant her emergency petition to begin divorce proceedings. While her divorce may have seemed like an “emergency” to her – her husband expected her to move out of the marital residence in the midst of the pandemic – the court did not agree. (Update: she has since been able to file since New York’s Office of Court Administration lifted an eight-week COVID-19 moratorium on all criminal and civil court matters as of May 25.)

While some courts’ physical doors are still closed and their services remain mostly frozen in time, there is little legal relief that the court can currently offer families in distress. But, there are alternative options to litigating a divorce in a courthouse. Divorce – and most family matters – can also be resolved through mediation. So, what is the benefit of mediating as opposed to waiting for the courts to reopen?

In mediation, you and your not-soon-enough-to-be-ex can work virtually with a trained mediator – a neutral third party who can help you reach an agreement tailored to your particular circumstances. The timing of a mediation session, or sessions, simply depends on your availability and that of the other party and the mediator. Mediation allows for your issues to be addressed and negotiated a lot quicker than waiting for a court to schedule your case amongst all the other cases the court is now scheduling, or rescheduling. More importantly, in mediation, you and your partner are the decision-makers – not a judge whom you have just met. You have the ability to control the outcome of your negotiations rather than leaving it in the hands of someone who does not know your family.

Our firm’s trained mediators have been conducting mediation sessions through videoconferencing to help parties resolve their family law matters while maintaining social distancing guidelines, saving the wait for a court date and fees to litigate. Whether the issues can be resolved in one session or more is also up to you – you can decide whether it is worth paying a mediator to continue negotiating. For questions or to schedule a family law mediation session, contact us today.

The Legal Intelligencer (online Family Law column), April 2020
Pennsylvania Law Weekly, May 2020

Unless you have been living under a rock for the last four weeks, you know how COVID-19 has upended the nation. The very limited upside of the pandemic is that it is allowing divorce lawyers time to rethink the provisions in routine marital settlement agreements and consider whether we need to include a “standard” force majeure clause.

This occurred to me in a case where one party was to retrieve personal items within a certain time frame in the agreement. When I followed up with my client, they told me that the personal property had not been retrieved because the movers cancelled—the moving company had been closed as a nonessential service. This brought to mind other instances where agreements feature obligations that must be carried out in a set sequence and the impossibility of those action items under current circumstances.

At their heart, marital settlement agreements, which set forth the parties’ rights and obligations in a divorce, are contracts. Case law, again and again, emphasizes that these agreements should be treated in accordance with standard contract law, notwithstanding the relationship between the parties. However, most commercial contracts include a force majeure provision regarding performance. In my 10 years of practice, I have never encountered such a provision in any of the marital settlement agreements that I have reviewed or drafted, but current events prove that such a provision is prudent.

A force majeure provision is the standard language that you see in tiny print at the bottom of the cruise ship boilerplate email after you paid your nonrefundable deposit, or your iTunes acceptance box, or really any routine “I accept” click. It is also present in any commercial contract where there is a building or other benchmark required to trigger payments. This is the provision that says if an act of God occurs, the responsibilities of the contracting parties become null and void. The clause usually contains a list of these sorts of things—floors, riot, declaration of war, hurricane, shortage of toilet paper, famine, pestilence, typhoon, fire, flood or declaration by state and local authorities. OK, so no shortage of toilet paper, but you get the idea. The short answer is that, generally, parties do not want their rights to become null and void, even if something unanticipated happens. Going forward, practitioners should think about including a provision to address the timing of the obligations, and perhaps other provisions, in their marital settlement agreements.

Specifically, where there is an act of God, the time frames set forth in the within contract must be modified. I suggest that certain financial adjustments, like payouts over time, can and should be able to be revisited in very limited circumstances. For example, if the parties sign an agreement that provides for a buyout of real property, and the subject house is destroyed by fire before the refinancing and buyout occur, it is reasonable for the agreement to allow for the parties to review the insured value of the house in light of the buy out. The burden for that act of God should not fall solely on one party, who is now homeless. Since insurance pays off any mortgage debt first, if the house is under-insured, one party may end up owing funds to the other based on the fair market value of a house that doesn’t exist, without funds to rebuild. In other words, if the parties owned the insurance policy together and it was underinsured, then there is no reason for only one of them to absorb the risk of the joint policy because of a slight question of timing. Likewise, if the house is overinsured, perhaps one party is not entitled to a windfall.

I am sure that every divorce attorney with agreements that include a retirement rollover for a specific amount lost some sleep when the stock market dropped 30% overnight. Financial risk is not considered an act of God, so a standard force majeure provision won’t help, but practitioners can include specific provisions to limit risks. My standard language for a Qualified Domestic Relations Order—or QDRO—is to set forth a certain sum as of a certain date, “plus or minus the investment experience from the date of the agreement to the date of segregation.” Simply put, the sum that my client is paying, or receiving, will track with the market. I’ve typically included that language because of the passage of time from when the agreement is completed until the QDRO is effectuated. However, I have two recent cases where opposing counsel insisted that a specific amount be transferred to each client, without any variance for the state of the market. For the last three years, this position was more favorable to their clients—the account holders—since the market only went up. In each instance, both of my clients agreed because they preferred to know exactly what amounts they would receive. In hindsight, both clients will now receive a greater share than anticipated, simply due to the timing and current market conditions.

To protect client interests, a good clause needs to be narrowly tailored, limited in time and clear as to the rights and portions encompassed. The provision must only apply to an unanticipated direct impact rather than indirect impact. If the marital residence burns to the ground, or a business is closed by government order, that might affect the distribution, whereas the indirect impact of an event on the stock market would not.

For practitioners who failed to include these provisions, the good news is that for a court to find a party in contempt, the party must have willfully failed to perform. If performance is impossible under current circumstances, it’s unlikely that the party will be found in contempt by a court. Moreover, it will be nearly impossible for the other party to appear before a judge on this issue while the courts remain closed.

My new force majeure provision is not ready for its Hollywood debut, but I think that, not only will this sort of provision be required for best practices, but also will become a part of standard practice. If marital settlement agreements are contracts, shouldn’t we review them with a more critical transactional eye? It is now apparent that doing so will benefit both the practitioner and client.

Reprinted with permission from the May 5, 2020, edition of Pennsylvania Law Weekly and the April 30, 2020, edition of The Legal Intelligencer (online) © 2020 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All rights reserved. Further duplication without permission is prohibited (contact 877-257-3382 or reprints@alm.com).

You’re engaged – Congratulations! After calling your family and friends, you probably Googled how to plan the perfect wedding, which led to lots of websites advising you on what steps you need to take. Somehow, between visiting venues and browsing Instagram and Pinterest for floral displays, the wedding planning checklists leave off what should become a standard part of preparing for marital success: consulting with a divorce attorney about whether a prenuptial agreement is necessary.

I know that this sounds like a shocking piece of advice. What could be worse for romance than visiting a divorce lawyer? Just like the wedding planners are putting into place all the components of a beautiful ceremony and the celebration thereafter, a consultation on your rights and obligations upon marriage can help couples think expansively and thoroughly about the future they are building together and how they want to prepare for it. Prenuptial agreements are not just for people with big family trusts or who are embarking on their sixth marriage – they are helpful to many other couples as well.

Prenuptial agreements are contracts that set forth the legal rights of two parties and financial arrangements including the distribution of each party’s assets in the event of divorce and, in some instances, death. Full disclosure: I am a divorce attorney who married without a prenuptial agreement. This was a deliberate decision on my part and is not one I regret in any way. I do not think that every person should have a prenuptial agreement, but I do think that this decision should be given appropriate consideration and is unique to each couple. For the countless clients I have represented in divorce, I wish they had met with a lawyer prior to their weddings so that they could understand how marriage fundamentally changes their legal relationship. Of course, in hindsight, each would agree that it is well worth the one or two hours of time to sit down with a divorce lawyer to help decide whether a prenuptial agreement makes sense. There’s a reason that clients often return for a prenuptial consultation prior to remarrying.

Here are three common misconceptions where having a prenuptial agreement may be helpful:

1. Keeping your finances separate doesn’t necessarily mean that splitting them up will be easy. I cannot tell you how often I speak with a potential client who is exploring divorce after a relatively short-term marriage who starts out with “this should be simple because we keep our accounts separate.” This only makes it simple if both parties earn the same income and spend money in the same way. When it comes to marital property, account ownership generally does not matter. For example: your spouse pays down their student loan every month while you pay into your retirement account. If you split up later, the increase in value of your retirement account is subject to division as marital property whereas their student loan payments simply reduced their premarital debt and doesn’t necessarily offset your retirement account growth. A prenuptial agreement can clarify who retains which accounts, without requiring a thorough accounting.

2. Everything you own is not automatically divided 50-50. The distribution of property acquired during marriage is equitable, which is not necessarily equal. The idea that you can simply divide everything in half and walk away only works if you both agree to that, in writing, prior to marrying. Typically, when a relationship is ending, it is because you cannot agree. A prenuptial agreement made in happier and calmer times can save on legal fees to negotiate the distribution of property in the event of a divorce.

3. Just because you owned something prior to marrying or acquired it from your family does not mean that it remains yours. When it comes to your grandmother’s bed, it is easy to say that it remains your property, but what about the family beach house in Avalon? While the initial gift remains yours – so long as it is not retitled jointly with your spouse – the increase in value of that gift is marital property, which means you may need to pay your spouse to retain a piece of family real estate or an inherited retirement account. Prenuptial agreements are a must when significant assets exist, or are anticipated in the future.

The good news is that each of these issues can be resolved up front with a prenuptial agreement, which can be as broad or as tailored as is appropriate to fit your situation. For example, the agreement could only encompass a share of the family beach house, or an inheritance, or could only address property distribution but remain silent on alimony. Even if a prenuptial agreement is not appropriate, nearly every couple would benefit from having conversations about long-term economic expectations and decision-making. You selected an alternate location for your outdoor ceremony in case it rains, right? Think of a prenuptial agreement as an insurance policy in the event of a rainy day.

One of the questions that I am often asked in consultations or in connection with dissolving a marriage is “What about college?” Many couples share an expectation that their children will pursue higher education. The real issue is how the cost – which may be sizeable – should be addressed.

Any family lawyer can tell you that presently, in Pennsylvania, there is no legal obligation to contribute to the cost of higher education beyond high school. A quick review of the support statute includes a specific provision, 23 Pa.C.S. 4327, which allows for the allocation of “postsecondary educational costs.” Passed in 1993, this statute applies to parents who are “separated, divorced, unmarried or otherwise subject to an existing support obligation,” which language was found to be a fatal flaw. In 1995, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that: 1) the allocation of secondary educational costs under this statute classifies young adults by the marital status of their parents; and 2) doing so was unconstitutional under the 14th Amendment, extending equal protection to individuals. See Curtis v. Klein, 542 Pa. 249 (1995). If parents in a married, intact household can choose not to contribute to their child’s education, then additional rights should not exist for parents who happen to live apart. I should note that our friends across the river in New Jersey are of a much different mind, and their Supreme Court, to date, has rejected the same equal protection argument that succeeded with the Supreme Court here.

Although parents in Pennsylvania have no legal obligation to contribute to college costs, they sometimes agree to do so in a marital settlement agreement. Pennsylvania courts tend to be friendly to contracts between married parties, so parties feel confident that the language of their agreements will be upheld. It is not uncommon for parties to bargain away certain rights or assets at the time of the divorce in exchange for a specific agreement on their children’s college costs. However, a recent Superior Court case suggests that, even when the agreement seems clear, there may still be additional defenses extended to this obligation.

In Weber v. Weber, 2019 Pa. Super 133, the parties’ adult son, Michael, sued Husband to enforce Paragraph 18 of his parents’ Marital Settlement Agreement. Paragraph 18 stated clearly and succinctly:

18. POST SECONDARY EDUCATION: Parents shall equally share the reasonable costs of an appropriate undergraduate college or other post-secondary education for the children.

The issue of Michael’s standing was litigated first; the Superior Court previously held that Michael had standing to pursue this action – thus this appeal had to do with the substance of the order. There were two primary issues before the trial court: 1) Could Michael sue Husband/Father for his half of the contribution to his expenses for undergraduate college and pharmacy school; and 2) Was Michael time-barred under a 4-year contract statute of limitations by the passage of time since his education terminated? Michael argued that the agreement was a continuing contract between the parties and that the statute of limitations did not apply. And, even if it did, he argued that the statute did not toll until he completed his pharmacy school education in 2015, so he would not be time-barred from bringing an action to enforce.

The trial court held that Michael’s attendance at pharmacy school was not contemplated by the “or other post-secondary education” section of the parties’ agreement; Husband/Father’s responsibility for contribution was only with regard to Michael’s undergraduate attendance. The court also found that Michael’s undergraduate education terminated in 2011, when he entered pharmacy school. The court agreed with Husband that Michael’s delay in filing for contribution until 2016 (which was one year after he completed pharmacy school) was barred by the 4-year statute of limitations since his relevant education terminated in 2011, and thus Michael was not entitled to relief, or any contribution, from Father. To no one’s surprise, Michael appealed.

On the second appeal, the Superior Court was slightly kinder to Michael than the trial court, but did not grant him the relief he sought. While the appellate court agreed that the Marital Settlement Agreement created a continuing contract with obligations that would stretch over many years, they disagreed that a continuing contract would not be subject to the statute of limitations as Michael argued. As such, the Superior court agreed with the trial court that Michael’s pharmacy degree was a graduate degree outside of the scope of Paragraph 18 and that Michael’s completion of his undergraduate education tolled the statute of limitations. Notwithstanding that Husband/Father had agreed to pay half, and then failed to uphold his agreement, Michael was not entitled to relief.

From a practitioner’s standpoint, we have a few “best practice” options in light of Weber – one is to advise clients of the myriad of difficulties in enforcing these kinds of provisions within the court system. Another is to understand that a general statement, i.e., “The parties shall share the reasonable expenses of college as hereafter agreed, in accordance with their abilities when the child enters college,” will not allow for any meaningful enforcement.

If Weber teaches us anything, it is that even an obligation to “share equally” has a lack of clarity (what exactly is being shared?) and a ticking clock for enforcement. If parties do agree to a specific allocation of expenses, attorneys need to be very specific as to what expenses are encompassed and, possibly, to make clear that enforcement of the provision must happen within a specific time frame; or, include a specific waiver on that point. Finally, if the parties insist, the agreement should include a provision that a qualified third party can determine the allocation of college expenses at a future date, perhaps either by arbitration or even by a specific arbitrator, which will allow some certainty and finality for all parties.

Margy Klaw and Eileen Murphy had fun with this topic when speaking with Wharton MBA candidates and Penn law students today. The event was sponsored by Wharton’s Common Cents Club, founded earlier this year. Common Cents is “focused on promoting Personal Finance literacy among the Wharton MBA community.”

Although family pets are near and dear to our hearts, there are no pet custody laws in either Pennsylvania or New Jersey. Bottom line:  have your family law attorney help negotiate an agreement.

It’s unfair to be too critical of lawyers who are quick to throw up their hands at preliminary junctures of civil disputes and repeat the oh-so-common mantra, “See you in court!” After all, we were trained in law school to be zealous advocates and the judicial system is geared to reward steadfast—sometimes just plain obstinate—adherence to a “strong” legal position. Consistently pounding the law, even when connection to the facts is tenuous, often results in victory and, in most situations, at least produces even odds of success. Certainly, there are some situations that cannot be resolved without the Solomonic authority of a master, judge or jury to decide a close call or to end a meritless rampage by misguided litigants or their lawyers. But participants in many civil disputes would be far better served if their lawyers had resources other than the relentless advancement of a specific position. Certain family law matters—for example, the financial issues associated with divorce-separation and the details of parenting arrangements between capable adults—are particularly well-suited for an approach that looks beyond the traditional “position-based” outlook we learned in law school and have practiced for years. In position-based negotiations, attorneys identify the relevant legal principles and search for facts that strengthen their client’s and diminish their opponent’s chances of success on each point. Successful lawyers come up with the strongest or most creative arguments on both sides of an issue and, with experience, learn to present the supporting facts in the order that will be most likely to attract the attention of the fact-finder. When done well, it’s not easy work, but the parameters are well-defined, leaving no impetus to think outside the box.

Comparatively, it’s much tougher work for lawyers to approach conflict resolution from a perspective that focuses on the interests of all parties and the nonparties who are directly affected: children, in family cases; employees and customers, in business cases; community members, in government and neighborhood disputes, etc. Interest-based negotiation—a relatively new addition to law school curricula, if available at all—presents challenges to the traditionally trained lawyer. There are two common intellectual obstacles: Isn’t a lawyer ethically obliged to view legal matters with blinders, focusing exclusively on winning the point for the client? Won’t business development be hindered absent a go-for-the-jugular reputation?

With the emergence of collaborative practice, clear ethical guidance is available to help answer the first question: Yes, it’s OK for a lawyer to provide limited representation. The collaborative practice begins with the parties’ agreement to reach a settlement but not to litigate if negotiations fall apart, consideration for the interests of all stakeholders and not just the client in fashioning agreements, and to openly call out a client for concealment of relevant information or bullying negotiation tactics. This doesn’t mean that there’s no room for lawyering in a collaborative process, but the problem-solving becomes more creative and expansive when advocates have the freedom to look at the situation from more perspectives than simply “winning” for their client.

As for the effect on a lawyer’s ability to attract business, there will always be those clients whose knee-jerk reaction to legal claims is to hire the biggest and meanest braggadocio in town, but today’s potential clients are progressively seeking more civilized and less costly ways to resolve controversies. They search online for “divorce without court,” “DIY parenting plans,” “friendly breakups,” and the like; they ask for a single lawyer to dissolve their small business or marriage because “we agree about everything;” and they make their expectations clear: “I want to resolve the problem but I don’t want to [pay to] go to court.” Call it wishful thinking, but I see plenty of business for lawyers who also buy into the notion that a “victory” refers to the dignity and respectfulness of the process and the parties as much as the whole tit-for-tat of the outcome. Modern clients want lawyers to be advisers who assist them in more civilized solutions to problems and do not promote litigation.

The most difficult part of reshaping a “see you in court” mentality is not figuring out how it jives with ethical mandates and marketing wisdom. It is realizing that the lawyer’s negotiating role doesn’t end with some polarized impasse over a legal issue; rather, that’s when it’s time to roll up sleeves, reconvene around the table and think of other ways to approach and resolve the disagreement. When “see you in court” isn’t an acceptable retort, lawyers are forced to think more creatively and not limit their clients’ options to the confines of narrowly defined positions.

For over three decades, I was one of those family law attorneys who wrung my hands lamenting about the expense, inefficiency, hurtfulness and time-consumption of litigation, until it was time to end the conversation. A few years ago, I put my money where my mouth is: I stopped litigating, I only accepted cases as a mediator, as the advisor of a client in mediation with someone else, or as an advocate in a collaborative case. I started educating potential clients about alternative dispute resolution options before launching into an assessment of how strong each client’s case would be in a litigated setting. I stopped teaching the divorce law and procedure course my partners and I developed years ago when I realized I was mostly teaching law students how to litigate in a courtroom. Now, I promote replacement courses that start with understanding how the human brain responds to conflict and look for opportunities to point out to my longtime colleagues in the family law bar how restrictive and polarizing a position-based approach is. In short, I’ve become a zealous advocate for changing the family law bar from a litigation-focused group to creative advisors on healthier ways to resolve family breakups. I am convinced this approach is what the majority of clients will demand of us in the future, because it beats the “see you in court” environment some attorneys have allowed to dominate.

Reprinted with permission from the JUNE 21, 2017, issue of THE LEGAL INTELLIGENCER (online). © 2017 ALM Media Properties, LLC. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. All Rights Reserved.

Should courts enforce a private agreement provision requiring one parent to pay the other parent a specified fee when filing for a custody modification? The Pennsylvania Superior Court, in Huss v. Weaver, 2016 PA Super 24 (Pa. Super. 2016), says yes.

Huss involves two parties who were in a romantic relationship. In October 2008, they entered into a formal agreement stating that if a child resulted from their relationship, regardless of whether they ever married, they would share legal custody with Huss (“Mother”) having primary physical custody and Weaver (“Father”) having specified visitation rights. The agreement also specifies that if Father seeks any modification of the agreed custodial arrangement, he would have to pay Mother $10,000 per attempt. In November 2010, the parties had a son; Father filed a custody complaint one month later. The Washington County, Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas docket reflects numerous highly litigious filings by the parties, monthly through June 2011 and periodically thereafter.

In March 2013, Mother filed a civil complaint in Washington County, alleging a single count for breach of contract. In response, Father filed preliminary objections. In April 2013, Mother filed an amended complaint, adding causes of action for negligent misrepresentation and fraud; Father filed a second set of preliminary objections to the amended complaint in the nature of demurrers, alleging that the $10,000 modification provision of the agreement violated public policy and that the latter two causes of action were barred by the economic loss doctrine. In September 2013, the trial court entered an order sustaining Father’s preliminary objections by finding that the “$10,000 clause” was against public policy and dismissed Mother’s complaint with prejudice.

Mother’s filings asserted that Father was an attorney at a large firm in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania and that he, along with a work colleague, drafted the October 2008 agreement. Mother further alleged that she was a real estate agent who had sought legal representation from Father on several legal matters in the past and that Father had told Mother that the entire agreement was enforceable at the time it was signed. Neither party was represented by independent counsel prior to signing the agreement. Although the agreement itself does not set forth the parties’ incomes, the recitals state that Mother is a real estate agent capable of earning large commissions if she works excessive hours and that Father is an attorney capable of earning a large salary. So, presumably, Father had the ability to pay the $10,000 fee.

Mother appealed the trial court’s September 2013 dismissal, raising the following issues:  1) did the lower court err in concluding that the parties’ agreement was not enforceable as a matter of public policy; and 2) whether Father, an attorney who drafted the agreement, should be estopped from asserting that the contract is unenforceable when he advised Mother that the contract was legal and enforceable?

When analyzing the first issue on appeal, the Superior Court sought the guidance of Ferguson v. McKiernan, 596 Pa. 78, 940 A.2d 1236 (Pa. 2007), which held that “in assessing whether a contractual agreement violates public policy. . . public policy is to be ascertained by reference to the laws and legal precedents and not from general considerations of supposed public interest. As the term ‘public policy’ is vague, there must be found definite indications in the law of the sovereignty to justify the invalidation of a contract as contrary to that policy. . . . Only dominant public policy would justify such action. In the absence of a plain indication of that policy through long governmental practice or statutory enactments, or of violations of obvious ethical or moral standards, the Court should not assume to declare contracts . . . contrary to public policy.” 

In Huss, the trial court relied on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision in Knorr v. Knorr, 527 Pa. 83, 588 A.2d 503, 505 (Pa. 1991)) in which the Court held — in the context of child support — that parents have no power to “bargain away the rights of their children” and that if a child support agreement between parents provides less than required or less than can be given, courts may ignore any agreement between parents and require a satisfactory level of support. Thus, the trial court concluded that the “$10,000 clause” was against public policy because enforcing it would “substantially impair the Court’s power and the Commonwealth’s duty to determine what is in a child’s best interests.” But the Superior Court found that there was not any dominant public policy grounded in governmental practice, statutory enactments or violations of ethical or moral standards, which provides a basis for declaring the “$10,000 clause” in the agreement unenforceable against public policy.

The Superior Court further stated that they did not see the “$10,000 clause” as a mechanism for prohibiting Father from seeking a modification of their custodial arrangement since there was no evidence in the record to indicate that paying that amount would be a hardship or roadblock to Father’s ability to petition. The trial court order was reversed, and the case was remanded with no need to address Mother’s second question:  whether Father should be estopped from asserting that the contract was unenforceable.

One dissenting opinion was issued, stating that a contractual provision which potentially hinders or chills an interested party’s ability to ensure a custody arrangement which is in the child’s best interest is against public policy and unenforceable. From a practitioner’s perspective, I do not see how a provision for payments one agreed to make is any more chilling than any other consequence of filing a petition to modify such as the time it takes to litigate, the effect litigation will have on the children, the effect litigation will have on the parties’ ability to co-parent or the chance that the modification will be less satisfactory. While there is still no appellate authority in Pennsylvania on whether parents are permitted to bargain away their or their child’s rights in custody agreements, courts are not barred from issuing a contrary disposition if it is in the best interests of the child to do so.  See Lee, et ux. v. Child Care Service Delaware County Institution District, et al., 461 Pa. 641, 337 A.2d 586, 590 (1975); see also Miller v. Miller, 423 Pa. Super. 162, 620 A.2d 1161, 1165-66 (Pa. Super. 1993).

In light of Huss, family law practitioners should not only advise clients on provisions that clearly would not work, but also consider leveling the playing field when negotiating custody agreements. Adding a provision for the filing party to pay a certain percentage of the non-filing party’s litigation expenses and maybe capping those payments at a specific level when modifying an already agreed to provision, perhaps within a specific time frame, will serve the best interests of children by discouraging unmeritorious litigation.

NOTE: Reprinted from Margaret Klaw’s online Huffington Post blog (12/09/13).

I ran into Sarah, a friend who also happens to be a former client, at a holiday party last week. As we chatted about her kids coming home from college, mine arriving from Brooklyn, and our respective plans for the holiday week, she suddenly got quiet. “I lost Christmas in the divorce,” she said. I had to ask her what she meant.

Sarah is Jewish. She was married to a man for seventeen years who is Catholic. Christmas, in his extended Italian family, was huge. Newly-wed at 23, Sarah immediately embraced the holiday. She had grown up with movies, Chinese food and a feeling of loneliness every December 25th. She loves big family celebrations; she loves cooking and entertaining and decorating. She and her former husband have three kids together, and they raised them with both Hanukkah and Christmas — the richness of the two traditions woven into the fabric of their childhood. When Sarah and her ex divorced and had to figure out how to share the holidays, it was a given that he got Christmas. Why shouldn’t the kids continue to have the feast of the seven fishes and homemade ravioli at Nini’s house? Why shouldn’t they continue to be with him around the tree on Christmas morning, opening presents? After all, he is the Christian and she is the Jew.

Divorce lawyers always have a lighter load when negotiating custody agreements for couples of different faiths. Especially when it comes to Christmas, because no holiday holds more psychic weight on the parenting front. Everybody wants to have their children with them on Christmas morning to experience the magic of waking up to the heap of presents under the sparkling tree. So when Dad is Jewish or Muslim and Mom is Christian, we breathe a sigh of relief. No argument about who gets that Holy Grail of holidays.

What I never knew, though, until this conversation with Sarah, is how difficult that can be. She internalized those Christmas rituals. Over the course of nearly two decades of married life, they became hers as well as his. She perfected her frosted gingerbread boys and pizzelles. She stayed up into the wee hours wrapping and hiding gifts. She anticipated the traditions with pleasure every December. And now that’s gone, and despite the fact that she very much wanted to be divorced, it’s a real, and unanticipated, loss. Before she remarried (also to a man who’s Jewish and was formerly married to a Catholic), she spent several Christmases alone. Her kids were with their dad, and no friends thought to invite her to share in their Christmas rituals. Which she understood: why would they, when they know she’s Jewish?

It struck me that this is part of the unavoidable fallout of divorce, the part that occurs after we divorce lawyers have completed our work. After the real estate and the retirement accounts and the living room furniture are divided up, after the papers are signed and the divorce decree is issued by the court, these emotional losses reveal themselves, even to people who are happy to be divorced. The loss of family traditions particular to one spouse’s culture, like the disappearance of friends whose primary loyalty lay with the other spouse, are intangible “assets” also subject to division.

But families do adjust and move on. Sarah told me that she and her children now find themselves every December 26th enjoying a new tradition, “Christmas Part Two,” complete with gifts, frosted gingerbread boys and pizzelles.

Archives

Categories