Category: Same-Sex Marriage

BKW Family Law is thrilled to announce our recent win before an en banc panel of the Pennsylvania Superior Court, in a groundbreaking triumph for families and LGBTQ+ rights in the Commonwealth. The ruling in favor of our client, the intended parent of a child born to a same-sex couple, solidified their legal recognition and parental rights. This momentous decision not only marks a significant victory for our client and BKW but also stands as a beacon of progress and inclusivity in family law.

The case centered around a same-sex married couple, where our client was the non-biological parent.  We sought to confirm our client’s parentage prior to the birth of the child.  Despite the increasing acceptance of diverse family structures, same-sex couples often face legal hurdles when it comes to establishing parental rights. This case, however, challenged the status quo and aimed to redefine the legal landscape for LGBTQ+ families as well as married couples with fertility challenges.

BKW’s legal team argued that under already existing case-law, the non-biological parent must be considered a parent to the child.  Further, we argued for the adoption of an intent-based approach to determining parentage, emphasizing the importance of treating all parents, regardless of sexual orientation or biological connection, with the same rights and considerations.

Central to this case as with any was the assertion that recognizing the legal rights of both parents is in the best interest of the child. The appellate court en banc considered the contractual obligation entered into by the parties as well as the clear intent by both that the non-biological partner was indeed intended to be a parent to the child.

In this huge win for our client and LGBTQ+ families throughout the Commonwealth, this decision granting legal recognition to the non-biological parent affirms the principles of equality, acknowledging that parental rights should not be contingent upon biological ties or the gender of the parents. BKW will continue to advocate for and value all families as we always have.

Review of Hollywood on Netflix

As a single person living and working from home during this pandemic, binge-watching television has become an important part of my new normal. I often devour hours of content per sitting, sometimes while having virtual watch-parties with friends who are doing the same. In these dreadfully uncertain times, I find myself continually seeking out quality content that is not only entertaining, but also that temporarily transports me to a different – and ideally a better – place. No show has met this need quite as well as the new Netflix series, Hollywood.

Set in the 1940s and featuring both fictional and real-life characters, Hollywood brings to life a reimagined history. The series suggests an answer to the question: What if those in power 80 years ago had demanded that women, people of color and LGBTQ people be given opportunities in the film industry?

The series features two interracial couples. Writer Archie (Jeremy Pope) is black and his boyfriend, aspiring actor Rock Hudson (Jake Picking), is white. Director Raymond Ainsley (Darren Criss) passes as white, despite his Filipino heritage, and his live-in girlfriend, aspiring actress Camille (Laura Harrier), is black. Camille is fighting for the leading lady role in Archie and Raymond’s movie which, even in this revisionist world, is a controversial choice given that the leading man is a white actor.

In 1930, the Motion Picture Production Code (also known as the Hays Code) expressly forbade the depiction of romantic relationships “between the white and black races.” At the time, anti-miscegenation laws prohibited couples of different races from marrying in the majority of the United States, including in California until 1948. It wasn’t until 1967 that the Supreme Court in Loving v. Virginia decided that laws banning interracial marriage were unconstitutional. And of course, it wasn’t until the 21st century that same-sex marriage became legal anywhere in the United States; national marriage equality finally happened in 2015, when the Supreme Court in Obergefell v. Hodges found that laws banning same-sex marriage were unconstitutional.

In 1949, the movie “Pinky” was released, about a light-skinned black woman who, while passing as white, studies to become a nurse and falls in love with a white man. Given the premise of the movie, this would have been a perfect opportunity to cast a black woman in a leading role, but even though both Dorothy Dandridge and Lena Horne auditioned, the studio decided to cast a white woman, who went on to receive an Academy Award nomination for the role.

If you are looking for a show to binge-watch while you are stuck at home during this pandemic, and you relish the glamour and the salaciousness inherent in a Ryan Murphy production, check out Hollywood. Like me, you may find yourself asking, “How would a major motion picture written by a gay black man and starring a black woman in the leading role have changed our cultural and legal landscape many decades ago?”

I would love to hear what you think!

BKW Law Clerk and Drexel-Kline School of Law 3L, Phill Sylvester, married his partner Matt Vendetta on December 8. BKW Law Clerk Caroline Osborne, also a 3L at Drexel-Kline, served as a member of the wedding party (2nd from right). And, last, but not least, Partner Megan Watson officiated.

Phill now affectionally refers to Matt as his “ex-boyfriend!”

Jennifer Dumin, The Legal Intelligencer (online)

Throughout America’s history, same-sex couples have stood before their families and friends and made declarations of love and commitment. I have attended commitment ceremonies over the last two decades that ranged from a dozen people standing in a circle in the backyard, to a service that included a pastor, a rabbi, two brides in pristine white wedding gowns and over 300 guests.

Sabrina Maurer and Kimberly Underwood held a commitment ceremony in New Jersey on Sept. 2, 2001, before relocating to Doylestown the following year. At the young age of 44, Underwood died in 2013, six months to the day before same-sex marriage was legalized in Pennsylvania. After Underwood’s death, Maurer experienced a plethora of disadvantages due to the couple’s nonmarital status: “I was denied life insurance payment, I was denied survivor benefit, I had to pay inheritance tax on 50 percent of joint checking, joint savings [and] joint investment accounts,” she stated in a NewsWorks article. Presented with this case, on July 29, Bucks County Court of Common Pleas Judge C. Theodore Fritsch Jr. signed a declaration of the validity of marriage, finding that the couple had entered into a valid and enforceable marriage under Pennsylvania common law. Despite the fact that New Jersey abolished common-law marriage in 1939 (N.J.S.A. 37:1-10), Fritsch ruled that the couple was married under the laws of Pennsylvania from the date of their commitment ceremony in New Jersey, until the time of Underwood’s death. Fritsch found:  “Their marriage is valid and enforceable, and they are entitled to all rights and privileges of validly licensed, married spouses in all respects under the laws of the commonwealth of Pennsylvania.”

As my colleague Lisa Shapson wrote in her column published May 1 in The Legal, “Validity of Common-Law Marriages,” “Common-law marriage is the concept that a state recognizes couples who never went through the process of obtaining a marriage license provided each party had the capacity to enter into a marital relationship – i.e., were of legal age to marry, not married to anyone else – and each party mutually consented to be husband and wife and held themselves out to the community as married.” Although Pennsylvania abolished common-law marriage effective Jan. 1, 2005 (23 Pa.C.S. Section 1103), unions that have met the statutory requirements for common-law marriage entered into prior to that date are valid.

Family law practitioners in Pennsylvania encounter questions related to common-law marriage when a client seeks assistance in dissolving a relationship that began before common-law marriage was abolished. Armed with evidence that may include proof such as cohabitation, commingled finances, and having children together – but which must include proof that the couple explicitly expressed words of present intent to be married – we file a divorce complaint, as we would for any other marriage. If we anticipate that the common-law marriage will be contested, as is often the case when an economically disadvantaged party is attempting to establish marriage for the purpose of securing property and support rights, it is good practice to file a motion requesting declaratory judgment of the validity of the marriage. When there is no objection from either party regarding the validity of the common-law marriage, e.g., when one party is deceased, as was the case before Fritsch, the court will find that there was a common-law marriage if presented with sufficient evidence.

Notably, at the time of Maurer and Underwood’s commitment ceremony in New Jersey in 2001, same-sex marriages were not legally recognized by any state in the country. Same-sex marriage did not exist in New Jersey until Oct. 21, 2013. Therefore, at the time of their commitment ceremony, neither party could have believed she had entered into a legal marriage.

On May 20, 2014, U.S. District Judge John E.Jones III of the Middle District of Pennsylvania ruled that Pennsylvania’s 1996 statutory ban on recognizing same-sex marriage was unconstitutional, making Pennsylvania the 19th state to sanction same-sex marriage. Jones found:  “By virtue of this ruling, same-sex couples who seek to marry in Pennsylvania may do so, and already married same-sex couples will be recognized as such in the commonwealth.” Prior to this ruling, same-sex couples were considered legal strangers under Pennsylvania law. Throughout the decades leading up to this ruling, these couples had to seek alternative measures to protect themselves, due to the inability to obtain recognition of their relationships as marriages under the law. Attorneys drafted documents such as cohabitation agreements enforceable in civil court, and assisted with death planning measures taken to protect individuals in these relationships to the fullest extent possible under the laws at the time. Of course, these options were, and continue to be, woefully inadequate when compared with the rights and responsibilities attendant to a legally recognized marriage.

Same-sex unions have existed at least since the beginning of recorded history. The first public gay wedding in the United States was in 1968, and in 1970, the first lawsuit seeking legal recognition of a same-sex marriage was filed. In 1987, during the week of the Second National March on Washington for Lesbian and Gay Rights, there was a mass celebration in front of the IRS building known as “The Wedding,” involving about 2,000 same-sex unions. The use of the term “commitment ceremony” as applied to same-sex couples has existed at least as far back as 1990, when it was used both at Hawaii’s first gay pride parade and at a Methodist church ceremony in North Carolina. Commitment ceremonies were popular in the late 1990s and throughout the 2000s.

It is difficult to imagine that these couples anticipated that their commitment ceremonies would eventually be recognized as the beginning of a legal marriage. Indeed, the reason many of these couples rushed to the courthouse after the laws changed in New Jersey and Pennsylvania was because they knew that the vows they had exchanged at their commitment ceremonies did not create legal marriages. So, what about those who have decided not to legally marry? Is it reasonable for one of them to later argue that they are married? Additionally, as a family law attorney who routinely prepares prenuptial agreements for opposite-sex couples who are about to get married, I wonder if the same percentage of same-sex couples might have taken similar measures had they believed they were committing to a legal marriage.

Fritsch’s ruling, which has created quite the buzz amongst family law attorneys, raises the question:  What is the legal relationship status of the same-sex couples in Pennsylvania who had commitment ceremonies prior to the abolition of common-law marriage, at a time when there was no recognition of same-sex marriage? Are they legal strangers, married couples, or something in between? This remains an open question.

Stay tuned.

Reprinted with permission from the SEPTEMBER 14, 2015 issue of THE LEGAL INTELLIGENCER (online). © 2015 ALM Media Properties, LLC. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. All Rights Reserved.

Jennifer Dumin and Lisa Shapson, The Legal Intelligencer

One year and one day after same-sex marriage became legally recognized in Pennsylvania, some friends exchanged vows. These newlywed wives want a child and are planning to start trying in the fall, with one as the birth mother, using anonymous donor sperm. I got a call from the to-be birth mother, asking the question on a lot of same-sex couples’ minds these days:  “Now that we’re married, will my wife automatically be legally recognized as one of the two mothers of our child or will she need to adopt our baby?”

From a practitioner perspective, the answer is easy:  Better safe than sorry. Proceed with an adoption. “But she’s going to be listed on the birth certificate as the second mother. Isn’t that enough?” A nonbirth mother may be listed on the child’s birth certificate as the second parent regardless of whether the mothers are married to each other, but this is not dispositive as to parentage. Similarly, in the case of unmarried opposite-sex parents, the fact that the father’s name is listed on the birth certificate is not conclusive proof of paternity. This makes sense, as there is no requirement that a father sign an acknowledgment of paternity form in order to have a birth certificate issued. An unmarried mother has the option of naming whomever she wants to be the other parent on the child’s birth certificate, or she can leave that part of the form blank. So, in cases where opposite-sex parents are not married when the mother becomes pregnant or when the child is born, the child does not have a legal father until paternity is established, either by filing an acknowledgement of paternity or by court determination of paternity.

For the purposes of this article, we are restricting our discussion of same-sex parents to those in which both spouses are legally recognized as female, irrespective of sex assigned at birth or gender identity, and where one of the two is the birth mother. Clearly, in all circumstances where there is a surrogate birth mother, such as is the case with same-sex parents who are both male, and neither is a transgender male who is the gestational parent, obtaining a court order adjudicating parentage is unavoidable.

Conclusive evidence of paternity can be rather effortlessly established by the father signing an acknowledgement of paternity in the hospital or at a later time. There is no parallel document such as an acknowledgment of maternity, and simply listing the nonbirth mother on the birth certificate is not sufficient. So, for married same-sex female parents, a second-parent adoption is currently the only infallible method for protecting against any challenges to the nonbirth mother’s parentage that may arise.

From a civil rights perspective, the answer to the question of whether a second-parent adoption is a necessary step for same-sex married couples is more complex:  If recognition of same-sex marriage is meant to extend all of the rights and responsibilities associated with opposite-sex marriage, shouldn’t all policies and practices that legally create and protect families apply to everyone?

One  of  the  benefits  of  marriage  for opposite-sex couples with children lies in Pennsylvania’s paternity laws. When issues of paternity are raised regarding these parents, the court applies the legal fiction known as the doctrine of the pre-sumption of paternity. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has stated, “The pre-sumption of paternity embodies the fiction that regardless of biology, the married people to whom the child was born are the parents,” in Brinkley v. King, 549 Pa.241, 701 A.2d 176, 180 (1997).

There are many ways in which children born of opposite-sex marriages benefit from this presumption of paternity, automatically having two parents with legal status. These children are eligible for health benefits from both parents. Both parents can provide consent for medical care should the children become ill. If one parent dies or becomes incapacitated, the surviving parent can continue to parent the children without facing potential challenges to custodial rights that nonparents may face. These children are eligible for Social Security survivor benefits for the death of a parent. They have intestate rights. If the parents separate or divorce, these children benefit from the financial and custodial support of two parents. The paternity presumption, despite being a legal fiction, is nonetheless an effective practice for legally recognizing two parents, giving all of these benefits to children and their families.

So, where does this leave those friends, who want their child to enjoy all of the benefits of having two legally recognized parents? Fortunately, Pennsylvania has allowed same-sex second-parent adoptions since 2002, per In re Adoption of R.B.F. and R.C.F., 803 A.2d 1195 (Pa. 2002). Unfortunately, in practical terms, this means shelling out a few thousand dollars in legal fees and undergoing scrutiny of their personal lives with home studies in order to have the same protections that opposite-sex married couples are automatically granted based solely upon their marital status.

In order to ensure that all families in Pennsylvania are treated equally under the law, and to protect the best interests of all of our children, the need for change is clear. Recognition of same-sex marriage was meant to extend all of the rights and responsibilities associated with opposite-sex marriage to these families. In order to accomplish true equality, practical changes must be made to allow these intended families to have the same legal recognition of parentage, regardless of the gender identity of the parents, including the same parental rights and responsibilities should the parties divorce.

In the courtroom, the paternity presumption should be expanded to a presumption of parentage, applicable to nonbirth mothers in same-sex marriages, so that their parentage can be protected from the date of birth of their child without the necessity and expense of a second-parent adoption. Additionally, expanding the legally binding acknowledgement of paternity form to be usable as an acknowledgment of maternity, or simply of parentage, would be an easy, cost-effective way to actualize full equality under the law.

Reprinted with permission from the JULY 14, 2015 issue of THE LEGAL INTELLIGENCER (Family Law Supplement). © 2015 ALM Media Properties, LLC. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. All Rights Reserved.

Archives

Categories